It's been interesting to follow the rhetoric as Agile methodologies have moved from the fringe into mainstream software development circles. Software conferences no longer offer Agile as a sub-topic.... instead, they're stacked with leaders from the Agile community teaching on a myriad of (what are now considered) industry best practices. But along with this has come an increase in the volume of detractors, bent on opening the eyes of proponents to the error of their ways. Kathy Sierra, in 2005, reminded readers that this "Kool Aid" effect is just par for the course... and a good sign that a product is engendering passionate users. It seems users of methodologies are no exception, making her post is worth a second look in 2007.
Source: Kathy Sierra's Creating Passionate Users blog
Sierra maintains that for every passionate user out evangelizing {insert preferred methodology name here} to everyone they meet, a koolaid-hunter will do his (or her) best to make sure everyone knows that your passionate users have lost their minds. That they're victim of fads and marketing hype.
So, should we ignore detractors? Sierra reminded us that somewhere in their complaints we can likely find hints on places to improve - something that could feed quite naturally into our cycles of do-inspect-adapt. On the other hand, she warned, catering to them leads to the "Zone of Mediocrity", where we try to get everyone to love what we do... at which point, she explained "You're screwed". Read Sierra's Physics of Passion: The Koolaid Point.
The Agile software development approach will never be embraced by everyone - nor should it be. Agile software development simply is not the Silver Bullet that will magically solve everyone's software development woes. But, in the appropriate contexts, it has helped teams achieve some outstanding successes.
Sadly, Sierra has recently experienced the dark side of the Kool-Aid effect herself, with the incidental side-effect of increased readership on her blog, hence the resurrection of this useful and timely old post. Sierra is co-creator of the Head First book series (Head First Java, Head First EJB, Head First Servlets and JSP, and Head First Design Patterns), founded the successful Javaranch.com community, is a master trainer for Sun Microsystems, and a popular blogger on software useability issues.
Source: Kathy Sierra's Creating Passionate Users blog
Sierra maintains that for every passionate user out evangelizing {insert preferred methodology name here} to everyone they meet, a koolaid-hunter will do his (or her) best to make sure everyone knows that your passionate users have lost their minds. That they're victim of fads and marketing hype.
If you create passionate users, you have to expect passionate detractors. You should welcome their appearance in blogs, forums, and user groups. It means you've arrived. Forget the tipping point--if you want to measure passion, look for the koolaid point.Sierra noted that the most popular and well-loved companies, products, and causes have the strongest opponents, lauded by cohorts for having the nerve to speak out, even as the thing railed against gains momentum. She included Apple, Extreme Programming and Java in her list of entities with both fan clubs and strong opposition camps.
So, should we ignore detractors? Sierra reminded us that somewhere in their complaints we can likely find hints on places to improve - something that could feed quite naturally into our cycles of do-inspect-adapt. On the other hand, she warned, catering to them leads to the "Zone of Mediocrity", where we try to get everyone to love what we do... at which point, she explained "You're screwed". Read Sierra's Physics of Passion: The Koolaid Point.
The Agile software development approach will never be embraced by everyone - nor should it be. Agile software development simply is not the Silver Bullet that will magically solve everyone's software development woes. But, in the appropriate contexts, it has helped teams achieve some outstanding successes.
Sadly, Sierra has recently experienced the dark side of the Kool-Aid effect herself, with the incidental side-effect of increased readership on her blog, hence the resurrection of this useful and timely old post. Sierra is co-creator of the Head First book series (Head First Java, Head First EJB, Head First Servlets and JSP, and Head First Design Patterns), founded the successful Javaranch.com community, is a master trainer for Sun Microsystems, and a popular blogger on software useability issues.